Shares

Best Pool Pump Reviews – Top 10 Hottest List for Aug. 2020

Shares

If your house has a swimming pool, I’m assuming it’s your favorite spot in the home where you decompress after a long day of work, hang-out with your folks or just sit, dip your feet with a glass of Mai Tai and lose yourself in thoughts.

Quite evidently, your swimming pool holds a great importance to you, which is why you need to install a quality pool pump to ensure peak optimum water quality and flow. With so many models and distinctive features that the market has bombarded on you, choosing the right model is a headache you didn’t sign up for.

So our research team has done the hard part by narrowing down your options to 10 models. We spent days weighing in the pros and cons, comparing and contrasting multiple products side by side to zero in on these 10 models.

We know you don’t have all day, so we will cut straight to the chase. Here are our top picks and in-depth reviews of the 10 best pool pumps on the market in 2020:

Best Pool Pump Comparison:

10 Best Pool Pumps for 2020

Best pool pumps over dozens of competitive models from different brands listed below:

1. Pentair 340039 SuperFlo High Performance Single Speed Pool Pump - (Highly Rated, Well-Priced Product - Best of the Best)

More photo & price on Amazon.com

If you are wondering whether single speed pool pumps will be adequate, we can confidently assure you that it is. A glowing example of a highly efficient single-speed model is Pentair SuperFlo.

If it’s your first pool pump purchase, it can be a good starting point due to its simple and streamlined installation. This mini beast draws its power and torque from a robust and heavy-duty 1½ Horsepower 56 square flange motor.

We were also impressed by the rugged build quality, especially the thick-walled components. Mind you that it’s a self-priming pump, meaning it can clear its air passage and suction line on its own using air-water mixture.

In short, it can continue to circulate and pump water with maximum efficiency, despite the level of solid contaminants the water is exposed to. In layman’s term, it will make sure your pool pump serves you loyally for years with minimal maintenance. The addition of a large, see-through strainer basket is a great touch too.

What we liked

  • Should work fine for 14,000 gallons in-ground pools.
  • Self-priming motor.
  • Can be easily self-installed.
  • Can operate on both 115v and 230V. There’s a knob at the back panel to switch the volt. We highly suggest installing a breaker by an electrician if you are going to run it on 115V.
  • Comes with an over sized strainer basket.
  • Quiet compared to most single-speed pumps.

What we didn't like

  • Taking the filter lid on and off isn’t as easy as we would have liked it to be.

2. Hayward W3SP1580 Power Flo Pool Pump - (Amazon’s Top Pick)

More photo & price on Amazon.com

The PowerFlo LX model we are reviewing in this section is another very capable single-speed pool pump that’s powered by a 1 HP motor. It’s also available in a 1.5 HP motor version for larger pools. The 1 HP motor should be sufficient for 54” deep pools.

Power Flo models are specifically crafted for on-ground and above-ground pools. The heavy-duty, drip-proof and heat-resistant design of the motor is remarkable, to say the least. You don’t have to be a pro with tools to install this pump. You can even rotate the middle section of the pump up to 90 degrees to hook it up with your existing filter system by simply removing the 4 bolts at the back of the motor.

The unit comes with a 3-prong power cord and an extra large, transparent debris basket. A lot of users have complained that taking off and putting the lid o-ring back on becomes increasingly difficult with time. Our suggestion to resolve this issue would be to wash the surrounding area and underside of the lid with plain water once in a while.

What we liked

  • Can be easily self-installed.
  • Rotating it to 90 degrees to fit with the existing filter is pretty easy too.
  • Heavy-duty, heat and drip-resistant motor.
  • Large strainer basket.
  • High-flow impeller keeps the water flow rate and pressure at optimum levels.

What we didn't like

  • The strainer basket lid’s o’ ring can come loose or become tight very soon. But we have mentioned a fool-proof solution to this problem in the review above.
  • The motor isn’t self-priming.

3. Pentair 342001 Pool Pump - (Runners up)

More photo & price on Amazon.com

If you are wondering whether variable speed pool pumps are worth it, let us assure you that it is. Models like Pentair 342001, unlike most standard energy-hungry pumps, will save you a big chunk of money on your monthly electricity bill.

This is one of the very few models in this price range that operates on 115/208-230V and 50-60Hz frequency range, which makes it easily adaptable to practically any type of electrical installation in the US. We also loved the easy-to-access design of the wiring compartment.

It houses a quiet but powerful and super efficient 1.5 HP TEFC motor and offers 3-speed settings along with an override speed setting to cater to your specific needs. The 1.5 HP motor model is ideal for 20,000-gallon pools but that doesn’t mean you can’t use it in larger 30,000 saltwater pools. It will simply take more time to complete the cycle.

It also integrates a real-time 24-hour timer, allowing you to program the operation duration as per your convenience. If you have guests coming over, just run the pool for 30 minutes at max speed and bada bing!

Another big plus is that it remembers your previously chosen settings after restarting.

What we liked

  • 3-speed settings and an override speed setting.
  • 24-hour programmable timer.
  • Highly energy-efficient.
  • Can operate in 20,000-30,000 gallon saltwater pools.
  • Remembers your preferred settings.

What we didn't like

  • If you are using a chlorine generator, it will not start if you run the pump at low settings.

4. Hayward W3SP2600X5 Super Pump Pool Pump - (Best Value for Money)

More photo & price on Amazon.com

This single-speed pool pump boasts of a top-notch build quality, convenient setup and what’s even better, fuss-free maintenance and servicing. Most consumers complain about the resilience of the lid on their strainer basket.

To fix this minor but annoying problem, this Hayward model utilizes swing-away hand knobs to take off the strainer cover. Speaking of, the industrial size debris/leaf collector basket is huge enough to save you frequent trips to the trash can.

Depending on your pool size and depth, you can choose from anywhere between 0.5 HP to 2.5 HP motor. While the 2 HP motors have 2” input and output connection size while the 1.5 HP or smaller motors have threaded female 1 ½” fittings.

Make sure to use quality high-pressure PVC twist in adaptors for optimal results. We should also note that it doesn’t come with any power cord. If you’re buying this model for the first time, you will have to call an electrician to hard-wire it to your house’s breaker panel.

For optimal efficiency and safety, we’d advise running it on 220 volts. It’s a self-priming pump and once you have installed it correctly, it gets the job done at fabulous speed without making much noise and never misses a beat.

What we liked

  • Maintains a fantastic water flow once installed properly.
  • Drop-proof, double sided shaft seal, thermal overload protection help the motor function smoothly for several years.
  • Virtually whisper-quiet.
  • You can easily switch from 220v to 110v, if really necessary.
  • Can be easily self-installed following YouTube video tutorials.

What we didn't like

  • The instruction manual included with the unit isn’t that lucid.

More photo & price on Amazon.com

The powerhouse of this CSA and ETL-certified above-ground pool pump single-speed 1.5 HP heavy-duty motor that comes with all the basic accessories (e.g power cord, 3-prong plug, input and output adapter fittings to get you started right away.

It can offer up to 45-85 gallons per minute (GPM), depending on your pool size and as long as you hook up a 1 1/2" PVC and keep the filter and basket clean. You can set a timer on it as well to maximize energy efficiency and thus, save money on your power bill.

If it’s your first-ever pool pump purchase, just follow the manual and you will be able to self-install it without needing any special tools.

This pump is ideally suited for 24x52” above-ground pools but you can run it in smaller (14”) and larger pools (33”) as well without any issue.

What we liked

  • One of the most energy-saving single-speed pool pumps on our list.
  • Suitable for both small and large above-ground pools.
  • Doesn’t overheat.
  • Easy installation.

What we didn't like

  • The device doesn’t have a shut-off/on switch on it.
  • Not designed for in-ground pools.

6. XtremepowerUS 2HP Inground Pool Pump - (Editor’s Choice)

More photo & price on Amazon.com

Our list of the best pool pumps will be incomplete without the mention of this technically-sound and robustly built 2 HP dual-speed motor-powered pump. It offers a whopping 5280 gallons per hour and is equipped with 2” fittings for easy plumbing connection.

On an even brighter side, it’s a self-priming motor, meaning the suction power will remain at its peak for years to come without any additional maintenance. The pump is hardwired to operate on 110v-220v but you will be able to run it on 230v without compromising on the performance or safety.

We will give it one extra star for the perfect water pressure it maintains all the time. Like any top-of-the-line pool pump worth its salt, it does its job without making noise. Similar models with identical features and built quality we came across during our research cost almost twice as much.

What we liked

  • Very reasonably priced.
  • Whisper-quiet operation.
  • Easy-to-install and low-maintenance.
  • Upgrading to this model from your older model (of another brand) would be easier as XtremepowerUS uses the same wiring as most standard models.

What we didn't like

  • The lid on the strainer basket doesn’t have a gasket and takes some effort to seal properly.

More photo & price on Amazon.com

Pool pumps are a long-time investment and you won’t want to settle for a model with questionable build quality. Our expert research team understands that, which is why the next under the scanner is Harris H1572747. It’s mighty but silent motor is securely housed in a reinforced thermoplastic body with virtually invincible graphite carborundum mechanical seals on it and other body parts.

The pump is self-priming which further adds to its durability and is meant to operate on 115-220 volts. If you want to run it on 230 volts, we’d suggest installing a 20 amp breaker. It also packs a thermal overload protection which will automatically shut off the device if the operating temp cranks up beyond normal.

What we liked

  • Takes merely 20-25 seconds to build pressure.
  • Self-primes in 30 seconds tops.
  • Due to similar electrical connections, it’s very easy to replace with your old Hayward or Pentair pump.
  • Includes 2-inch PVC adapters in the box.

What we didn't like

  • Slightly noisy.

8. Pentair 011028 IntelliFlo VS Pool Pump - (Best Overall, Runners up)

More photo & price on Amazon.com

If you are in the market for a smart and tech-rich pool pump, your search could well end here. The IntelliFlo comes with a control keypad that lets you change the direction of the pump for optimal functioning all over the pool surface. It offers 8-speed settings and built-in timer. Pentair automation system brings all these controls on your smartphone so that you can program the pump remotely.

The powerful 3 HP variable speed motor is securely housed in a double-walled shaft and a built-in fan prevents overheating. Another top reason why this model is on our list is its energy-star rating. It is meant to consume 90% less energy than regular single-speed pumps. You know what that means for your monthly power bill, right?

What we liked

  • Energy-star rated.
  • 8-speed settings.
  • Can be rotated in any direction for a thorough coverage.
  • Quiet and steadily maintains optimal water pressure.
  • Easily programmable using mobile device, thanks to Pentair's automation and controls with mobile device, thanks to smart Pentair automation and controls

What we didn't like

  • You may need to call a professional for the installation.

More photo & price on Amazon.com

Here’s another dual-speed pool pump that does a fine job consuming minimal energy. It’s an ETL and UL certified equipment, meaning it meets the strict safety standards issued by the US government.

The self-priming motor is equipped with air-flow ventilation to keep the suction power high and thus, reduce pressure on the filter. The 2 HP hefty motor is adequate for 36,000 gallons or larger pools and two speeds help you fine-tune the pumping right according to your needs.

The unit also comes with 2” union fittings. All you have to do is buy the PVC NTP pipes and let an electrician do the installation for you. You can try DIY if you have prior experience of hooking up electrical connections. We’d also suggest running it on 240 volts only (it’s actually rated for 220/230V, ignore the mislabelling), if possible. Operating at high speed on 240 volts will eventually reduce the operation time, hence more energy-saving.

What we liked

  • Two-speed settings to cater to different pumping needs for various pool sizes.
  • Can run non-stop. It will auto shut off every 15 minutes for 10 minutes and start back to prevent overheating.
  • Quiet and highly energy-efficient.
  • Very affordable.

What we didn't like

  • The manual doesn’t come with any instructions about the electrical connections. Therefore, you will most likely need a pro to set up the thing for you.

More photo & price on Amazon.com

So your old Pentair model has a good run but now it’s high time for an upgrade. If that’s your situation then you might want to take a look at WhisperFlo. The motor size ranges from single-speed 0.5 to 3 HP.

The 0.5 HP model we are reviewing here is designed to run on 208/230v. Please check the operating voltage range if you are buying a higher horsepower device, since each of them have a different volt range.

Coming to the performance, it’s a self-priming pump and if everything is set correctly, it would be able to keep the water pressure steady at 14-16 psi in 14,000-gallon pools. You won’t be able to hear it unless you’re really paying attention. We’d highly recommend it for pools that are surrounded by lots of trees and get exposed to a lot of dust.

What we liked

  • Cost of running won’t leave a hole in your pocket.
  • One of the quietest pool pumps on our list.
  • Maintains a steady water pressure while running non-stop (15 psi, give or take).
  • See-through extra-large debris basket.

What we didn't like

  • The pump insurance policy guideline requires you to get the pump installed by a certified pool company or technician.

Final Verdict

We are done dropping our two cents, now it’s your turn to do your due diligence. Don’t jump to the conclusion only based on your hunch. Pick a model that fits your pool size, type, surrounding environment (i.e the level of pollution around the pool area) and of course, your budget.

It’s hard to just crown one model the best pool pump without considering all these vital factors. So take your time, read our reviews carefully, cross-check all the information we provided, if you must and only then finalize your purchase. We worked really hard to make sure you end up with the right product. So good luck to both of us.

Leave a Comment: